The second they went to replay, you could kind of feel where it was heading for Victor Wembanyama.

His elbow caught Naz Reid high, Reid hit the floor immediately, and once the officials started slowing it down frame-by-frame, it felt pretty obvious Wemby’s night was probably over. Honestly, judging by the reaction on the bench afterward, he didn’t seem all that shocked by it either.

That’s usually how these plays go in today’s NBA. Once contact up around the head or neck gets put under a microscope, especially in a playoff game, there usually isn’t much room left for the officials to talk themselves out of an ejection.

But a lot of people seem to think missing just that game wasn't enough.

"I'm Ejected?"

Before the ejection, Wembanyama wasn't taking over Game 4 or anything. He had four points, four rebounds and an assist in about 12 minutes, so this wasn’t one of those nights where he already had the entire game in a chokehold before getting tossed. But even when the numbers aren’t exploding, you still feel him out there. Every drive looks tighter because of his length. Minnesota still had to account for him on basically every possession, whether he was scoring or not.

The play itself came with 8:39 left in the second quarter and the Wolves hanging onto a two-point lead. Wembanyama grabbed the rebound, immediately got swarmed by Naz Reid and Jaden McDaniels, then swung through trying to clear space. The elbow connected, Reid dropped, and the entire arena instantly had that “uh oh” reaction before the replay even started rolling.

Then came the weirdest part of the whole sequence.

The broadcast caught Wembanyama on the bench after the announcement looking legitimately confused, leaning over and asking Harrison Barnes, "What does that mean?" before realizing he'd been ejected.

But once he understood what the call actually meant, he didn’t seem all that surprised by it either. If anything, it felt more like a player understanding that once the replay starts showing contact that high over and over again on the arena screen, there’s a pretty good chance your night is over.

San Antonio Didn’t Fold

The easy version of this game would’ve been Wembanyama gets tossed, the Spurs completely unravel, and Minnesota cruises the rest of the way. That’s usually how this stuff goes when a team loses their entire identity in the middle of a playoff game.

But San Antonio responded way better than most people probably expected. De’Aaron Fox and Dylan Harper both finished with 24 points, Stephon Castle chipped in 20, and there was actually a stretch there in the fourth quarter where it started feeling like the Spurs might steal the game anyway. They even built an eight-point lead late.

And that says a lot about this group, because losing Wembanyama in a playoff game should feel like somebody ripped the engine out of the car halfway through the race. Everything they do defensively revolves around him. The spacing changes because of him. The way teams attack changes because of him. Usually when a guy like that disappears, the game tilts quickly.

Instead, San Antonio kept swinging.

Eventually, though, Anthony Edwards did what stars tend to do in games like this. He completely took over late, scoring 16 of his 36 points in the fourth quarter while Minnesota finally settled things down enough to escape with a 114-109 win and tie the series at 2-2.

One Bad Elbow Didn’t Need To Become A Bigger Story

Some people immediately called the play dirty. Others acted like the league was trying to criminalize a normal basketball play just because it looked rough in slow motion. And somewhere in the middle of all that yelling is probably where the real answer is.

Because yeah, it was a bad elbow.

You can watch the replay ten times and still come away thinking the ejection made sense. But that doesn’t mean the NBA needed to take it any further.

Wembanyama doesn’t have some long history of cheap shots or losing control. This was the first ejection of his career. And truthfully, there’s at least a believable case that he knew Reid was there fighting for position, but didn’t actually realize just how high the elbow was going to land when he swung through trying to clear space.

Again, that doesn’t suddenly make it okay. It just matters when you’re deciding whether somebody deserves to miss another playoff game over it.

Spurs coach Mitch Johnson defended him hard afterward, saying there was “zero intent” and pushing back against the idea that more punishment was needed. And sure, coaches are always going to defend their stars. That part comes with the job. But he also wasn’t wrong when it came to the bigger picture here.

There’s a difference between punishing the play and turning one moment into some bigger statement about a player’s character.

The NBA already punished the play in real time. Wembanyama got tossed. San Antonio lost him for most of a massive playoff game.

That was enough.

Not every hard foul needs a suspension attached to it. Sometimes the best answer really is the simplest one: throw the player out, let everybody cool off for a couple days, and move on to Game 5.

All stats courtesy of NBA.com.

Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.