These Are America's Most Theft-Prone Beaches
You packed the sunscreen. You've got your towel. You left your phone, wallet, and keys sitting right there on the blanket while you went for a swim.
That last part might be the problem — depending on where you are.
A new analysis by The Action Network examined property crime data across more than 520 beach zip codes nationwide to rank US beaches by theft risk. The methodology factored in effective daily population — meaning tourist crowds, not just permanent residents — to calculate the actual likelihood a visitor would become a theft victim. The results are worth knowing before you pick your spot.
The Most Theft-Prone Beaches in America
North Jetty at Ocean Shores, Washington came in at number one with a 4.81% implied theft risk. Folly Beach in South Carolina came in second at 4.58%, with an adjusted property crime rate of 109.18 incidents per 1,000 people and an effective daily population of about 12,500.
Three North Carolina beaches cracked the top ten — Ocracoke lifeguarded beach ranked first in an earlier version of the study, with Currituck Beach and Carova Beach on the Outer Banks tying for seventh. However, the superintendent of Cape Hatteras National Seashore disputed the Ocracoke data, stating there hasn't been a single theft incident at the lifeguarded beach on Ocracoke Island in over a decade — a reminder that zip code-level crime data doesn't always reflect what's actually happening on the beach itself.
California put three beaches in the national top ten, with Santa Monica State Beach recording an implied theft probability of over 25% when vehicle theft rates are factored in. "Although many of these beaches are well-maintained and staffed with lifeguards, they're located in ZIP codes with elevated property crime rates," an Action Network spokesperson said. "That's not to say the beaches themselves are unsafe — but location matters."
The Safest Beaches
Major resort hubs came out on top for safety, with Maui's Kaanapali Beach ranking as one of the safest in the country. Heavily staffed resort beaches with controlled access, security personnel, and active lifeguard presence consistently showed lower theft rates than public beaches in urban areas.
What's Actually Being Stolen
Before you cancel your beach trip, some context. More than 92% of recorded incidents at high-theft beaches were non-violent — mostly unattended bags and rental car break-ins. Nobody is getting mugged in the surf. What's being taken is the stuff people leave sitting unattended on a blanket while they swim — phones, wallets, car keys, and the items visible through car windows in beach parking lots.
Rental car break-ins are the single biggest driver of elevated crime numbers at many beach locations. Thieves know rental cars are filled with tourist gear and that the owners are likely to be at the beach for hours. A duffel bag visible through a window is an invitation.
What You Should Actually Do
The practical advice hasn't changed much. Don't leave valuables unattended on the sand — ever, at any beach. Waterproof pouches that hang around your neck keep your phone and payment method with you in the water. A small combination lock dry bag or a portable beach safe that anchors to an umbrella stake is a $20 to $30 investment that eliminates the problem entirely.
For parking lots — take everything out of your car or put it completely out of sight in the trunk before you park. Not after you pull in, when someone might be watching. Before. The moment a bag goes in the trunk in a beach parking lot it becomes less interesting to someone walking by looking for an easy target.
The beach is still worth going to. Just don't make yourself an easy mark while you're there.
Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.