Vrabel Said It Out Loud: The Stars Have to Show Up
"When your best players don't play good, you don't have much of a chance in this league."
That's what Mike Vrabel said after Green Bay dropped 45 on the Patriots at Gillette Stadium last Sunday — the most points anybody's put up in that building since it opened in 2002. A week later, New England flew to Munich, lost Drake Maye to an ankle injury on the opening drive, and got steamrolled by Detroit, 35-10.
So here we are. They're 5-5 and heading into the bye with their quarterback waiting on more tests and a defense that's given up 80 points in two weeks.
Last year's 14-3 run to the Super Bowl leaned hard on two young stars playing so well that nobody had to look too closely at what was standing around them. Maye and Christian Gonzalez aren't pulling that off anymore. Some of that's on them. A lot of it isn't. The Packers game is the best place to sort out which is which.
Jordan Love Kept Going Back to the Same Well
Green Bay didn't need to get cute. Jordan Love threw for 372 yards, and a big chunk of it came from picking on the guy the Patriots just made the highest-paid corner in NFL history.
Gonzalez was targeted 11 times and gave up 10 catches for 187 yards and a touchdown. His previous career high for yards allowed in a game was 90. Matthew Golden caught all seven balls thrown his way for 105 yards, and Gonzalez became the only defender since 2018 to allow 80-plus receiving yards to two different players in the same game. He was pretty blunt about it afterward:
They got the best of me today. I had a bad game.
One bad game happens. The bigger issue is the trend. Last year, Gonzalez allowed a 43.4% catch rate and a 57.0 passer rating into his coverage. Per Fantasy Points Data, he's at 68.2% and 101.6 this year, which is a little worse than the league average for a corner. That's not the guy who just signed for four years and $135 million.
It isn't all on him, though. The Patriots have had busted rotations on quick snaps — Green Bay ran 10 of them and ripped off gains of 49, 43, 43, and 28 yards — and a zone defense that's allowing a league-worst +0.21 EPA per dropback. Kevin Byard's 33 and his recovery speed is showing. Craig Woodson's been sitting too shallow, which leaves the deep post wide open. Since Week 4, New England's given up 262.8 passing yards per game, second-most in football. Last year, after Week 10, they didn't let a single quarterback hit 200 yards the rest of the regular season.
Munich was more of the same, just with a twist. Amon-Ra St. Brown beat Gonzalez for a 56-yard touchdown on Detroit's first possession, then Gonzalez picked off a pass meant for St. Brown in the second quarter for his first interception of the season. That's kind of his whole year in one half. He can still make the big play. He's just not erasing anybody anymore.
What Last Year Was Hiding
Let's be fair to 2025. That team was good. You don't post a +170 point differential by accident.
But it also played the easiest schedule in football. Opponents went a combined .391, which was tied for the third-softest slate of the last 50 seasons. The offensive line was a patchwork job built around a rookie left tackle in Will Campbell because the front office couldn't land anybody better. The pass rush finished near the bottom of the league in sacks.
None of that mattered much, because Maye finished five voting points behind Matthew Stafford for MVP after leading the league in completion percentage (72%) and passer rating (113.5), and Gonzalez was about as good as it gets at corner. When your quarterback's basically a co-MVP and your top corner deletes one side of the field, a thin roster looks a whole lot thicker than it actually is.
Then Seattle sacked Maye six times in the Super Bowl, and we all got a little preview of what happens when the curtain gets pulled back.
Too Much on Maye's Plate
This year, the stuff around Maye got thinner, not thicker.
The Patriots lost 130 player-games to injury through nine weeks, and they've now used a league-high 42 different starters. A.J. Brown, who cost them a 2028 first-rounder, has 11 catches and a 47% catch rate in four games and left Munich with a hamstring injury. Romeo Doubs, the $68 million free agent, is on IR. Mike Onwenu's missed seven straight. TreVeyon Henderson just landed on IR, and Rhamondre Stevenson's been playing through a knee issue. The Packers game was the fifth different starting offensive line combination of the season, and both Campbell and Ben Brown left that one with knee injuries.
His receivers are dropping balls at the highest rate of his career, and defenses are blitzing him more than ever. So when the defense gives up 45, the offense basically needs Maye to be perfect. That's a brutal way to live.
What the Film Actually Says
This is where it's worth slowing down, because "Maye's struggling" and "Maye's line is struggling" are two different stories. Both are true. They just aren't the same thing.
The protection part is ugly. Per Fantasy Points Data, Maye's been pressured on 146 of his 319 dropbacks this season, right around 46%. The league average is closer to 35%. Green Bay got to him at a 51.2% clip early on Sunday.
Here's what jumped out, though: he's been really good under pressure. His EPA per dropback when pressured is +0.078. The league average under pressure is -0.294. Most quarterbacks fall apart when the pocket caves in. Maye's still finding ways to make it work.
Where he's hurting himself is in a clean pocket. Seven of his 11 interceptions have come when he wasn't pressured, and his clean-pocket EPA (0.207) actually sits a touch below league average (0.226). Eight of the 11 picks have also come against zone.
The Green Bay tape backs that up. On the killer second-quarter pick, Xavier McKinney read the slot release and jumped a crosser to rookie tight end Eli Raridon. Maye was expecting McKinney to stay over the top of Kyle Williams. On another, Mack Hollins was covered and the deep post was sitting right there. All three picks came on throws of 18-plus air yards. And only 22.8% of his attempts this year have gone to the middle third of the field. Against Seattle, Jacksonville, and Green Bay — the three defenses that leaned hardest on split-safety looks — he's thrown five picks and two touchdowns against two-high coverage.
Maye pretty much diagnosed it himself on WEEI:
Just looking at the film and clearing up about, you know, what I could have done better, how I can learn from it, and just keep on trying to, you know, have an aggressive mentality but also to be mindful of not being reckless. And Coach Vrabel always, you know, always says that. So, that's the mindset. And just get together with the teammates, coaches, and guys in the facility that realize we've got a band together and realize that we still have a lot of football ahead of us.
One Bad Day or a Confidence Problem?
I don't know if I fully buy the confidence angle, and the stretch before Green Bay is why.
From Week 4 through Week 8, Maye threw 14 touchdowns and two interceptions, ran for three more scores, and the Patriots went 4-1. He's accounted for at least three touchdowns in six straight games, the second-longest streak in franchise history behind Tom Brady's 10 in 2007. In Miami, he came back from 13-3 down at halftime without his top three receivers or either starting guard and went 9-of-10 for 140 yards with three total touchdowns in the second half. That isn't a guy who's lost his nerve.
What the Packers game looked like was September all over again. The six-pick, one-touchdown start to the season came against defenses that sat back in two-high shells and waited for him to force something. Green Bay came in third in pass defense DVOA and ran that exact blueprint, just better than Miami or the Jets could.
That's good news and bad news. A known blueprint is more fixable than a shaken quarterback. But the defenses that can run it are the ones left on the schedule. The Patriots are 3-0 against teams with losing records and 2-5 against everybody else.
At least nobody's hiding behind excuses. Maye said after Green Bay:
I wasn't good today. I feel like in the times we had chances to get back into the game, I messed them up.
Owning it and fixing it are two different things, though.
Can They Fix It Fast Enough?
Munich didn't help answer that. On the opening drive, a Campbell false start and a delay of game pushed the Patriots from the 3-yard line back to the 13, then Aidan Hutchinson sacked Maye on third down, and he walked off with the ankle injury. Vrabel didn't have a diagnosis after, only that "we'll have to get some more tests run." Tommy DeVito threw for 81 yards. Jahmyr Gibbs piled up 252 yards from scrimmage by himself — more than New England's entire offense.
The bye couldn't come at a better time. Then it's the Chargers, Bills, Vikings, and Chiefs back-to-back-to-back-to-back. Vrabel said the team has to "get some things fixed and changed and corrected" over the break, which is about as Vrabel as it gets.
Can they still be a playoff team? If Maye's ankle is a short-term thing, I think yes, barely. The film says his problem is fixable: stop forcing deep shots into two-high looks, take what's underneath and live to fight another down. But the secondary has to get fixed, too, and Gonzalez has to look like Gonzalez again, because the roster isn't going to fix itself.
Last year, the stars covered for everybody. Now they need everybody else to cover for them for a little while. I'm just not sure everybody else is healthy enough to do it.
All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.
Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.