Jeffrey Epstein's Death Likely Homicide, Not Suicide, Forensics Expert Claims
A leading forensics expert says Jeffrey Epstein's 2019 death in a New York jail was more likely a homicide than a suicide, challenging the official ruling. The New York City medical examiner's office, which ruled the death a suicide, says it stands by its findings.
Dr. Michael Freeman, editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, presented his findings Monday, Nov. 16, in London.
What the Forensic Expert Found
Freeman worked with Anders Eriksson, a forensic medicine professor at Umeå University in Sweden, and Itiel Dror, who studies bias in forensic decision-making. They reviewed autopsy records and photos provided by Epstein's brother, including records that had never been published, according to CBS News.
Freeman also built a 3D model based on the jail cell and Epstein's injuries.
He said the injuries documented by the medical examiner "were not consistent with the suicidal hanging." Among his key points, he identified a second ligature mark lower on Epstein's neck and angled differently from the first. "There is no mechanism to produce a second mark that would be lower," Freeman said, according to Newsmax.
Freeman also pointed to deep bleeding in Epstein's left shoulder, an injury to his back, blows to his face and possible fingernail marks above the ligature line. He said some of these injuries were overlooked or attributed to other causes.
A Strangulation Theory
Freeman believes the injuries are more consistent with Epstein being strangled from behind with a narrow, double-knotted strip of orange bedding fabric. That fabric was found in a corner of the cell but was never collected for the medical examiner, he said.
He also said it was not realistic that a "false start" in a suicide attempt could break the hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage in Epstein's neck while he remained conscious.
Freeman based his reconstruction partly on the account of correctional officer Michael Thomas, who said he found Epstein hanging from a bedpost. Freeman said some of the neck wounds fit a hanging, while others do not.
His report was rejected by an academic journal after reviewers objected to criticizing a medical examiner's findings in a peer-reviewed publication. Freeman plans to resubmit it.
Medical Examiner Stands by Suicide Ruling
The New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner declined an interview but defended its conclusion. "Our office stands by its determination," a spokesperson said.
In June, The New York Times reported that newly released documents and handwritten jail notes from Epstein indicated he intended to end his life. The Times also reported that most forensic experts it interviewed believed the manner of death could not be settled by medical evidence alone. A purported suicide note from Epstein was also released to the public in May.
A 2023 Justice Department inspector general report found that jail staff falsified records of inmate checks that were never performed and that nearly all cameras around Epstein's unit failed to record. But the report said it "did not uncover evidence contradicting the FBI's determination regarding the absence of criminality."
Questions That Have Lingered for Years
Freeman is not the first expert to question the ruling. In 2020, forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden, who was hired by Epstein's brother, told "60 Minutes" that the evidence pointed more toward homicide than suicide.
CBS News also noted problems with the original investigation. Epstein's body was moved within minutes of being discovered, and the cell was not sealed or properly preserved. Most cameras in his wing were not working, and investigators did not follow up on an unexplained orange blur seen on a nearby camera.
Medical examiner investigators did not interview the guards on duty, and two employees were criminally charged with falsifying records. Those charges were later dismissed after they complied with agreements with prosecutors.
The case remains a source of controversy, with a House panel recently rebuking the Justice Department's handling of the Epstein case.
Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.