The NBA’s Most Overlooked Impact Players This Season
Every season, the conversation gets dominated by the same ten names. SGA, Jokic, Luka, the usual suspects. And that's fair — those guys are doing things that deserve the attention.
But every once in a while, a season has a handful of stories living just below the surface. Players quietly making a real impact, either for themselves or their team, while the spotlight stays locked on the bigger names.
This is about those guys.
We're not talking about fringe rotation players racking up empty stats on lottery teams. We're talking about guys who are materially impacting winning basketball — and in a few cases, genuinely rewriting their own professional narratives — while seemingly flying under the radar.
Here are five players who deserve a bigger piece of the conversation right now.
1. Dylan Harper, San Antonio Spurs
The Rookie Who Knows His Lane
The draft night story was almost too easy to write.
Dylan Harper, son of five-time NBA champion Ron Harper, goes second overall to the San Antonio Spurs — a team fresh off back-to-back Rookie of the Year winners in Victor Wembanyama and Stephon Castle. On paper, it felt like he was walking into a situation where he’d be fighting just to be noticed. De’Aaron Fox is locked in on a max deal. Castle just won ROY. Wembanyama is… whatever Wembanyama is — a walking highlight that naturally pulls every bit of attention in the building.
So yeah, there wasn’t supposed to be much room here. Not for real minutes, and definitely not for a rookie to carve out any kind of identity early.
And yet, a few months in, Harper has become one of the more impressive rookies in this class — just not in the way people usually look for.
That’s really the key to all of this. Harper hasn’t tried to force anything. No heat checks, no chasing numbers, no trying to prove he should be “the guy” right away. He’s just stepped into what the Spurs actually need from him.
He’s coming off the bench as the sixth man, giving them about 22 minutes a night, and he’s been steady across the board — 11.3 points, 3.8 assists, 3.3 rebounds, right around 49 percent from the field. Nothing that jumps off the page at first glance, but if you watch it, it’s clean. It’s controlled. It fits.
He took home Western Conference Rookie of the Month in February — the only time all season Cooper Flagg didn’t win it.
He's Been Plug-and-Play in This System
The part that gets overlooked is the floor impact. Harper isn't just putting up decent lines in garbage time — he's been operating as a legitimate connector in San Antonio's offense. And you can feel it when he's out there. The ball moves a little quicker, and possessions don’t get sticky.
The pairing of Harper and Wembanyama in particular has been devastating, with the two sharing a +40.2 net rating in 12 games together. And it makes sense when you watch it. Harper is constantly putting pressure on the defense — he leads the team in drives per minute — and he’s not just driving to score, he’s reading the second defender, kicking it out on time, or dropping it off to Wemby in spots where he can go to work.
He’s also got the best passing feel of the Spurs’ young guards right now, and that shows up in the little stuff. He can keep a possession alive without overdribbling, and he’s already comfortable running the offense when Fox and Castle need a breather.
The background matters here, too. At Rutgers, Harper was dealing with a mid-season illness that limited him, and his shooting numbers took a hit. He still averaged 19.4 points, 4.6 rebounds and 4.0 assists, and NBA teams saw enough to draft him second in a class that included Flagg. The concerns coming in were about three-point shooting — he's at 29 percent from deep this season, which is a real thing to watch — and how he'd fit in a crowded backcourt.
He's answered the fit question pretty decisively. "Ball movement," he said recently when asked what's been clicking. "The biggest thing is just, how can we keep the ball popping? We can always get a good shot, but how can we get a great shot?"
He’s missed a couple of games recently with a calf contusion, which has briefly slowed down the conversation. But when he’s been on the floor, the impact has been real. He’s been a key piece in San Antonio’s 51-18 run — the Spurs’ first 50-win season since 2016-17 — and during his best stretch in February, they just didn’t lose.
Two things can be true at once: this is a crowded backcourt situation that naturally limits his ceiling this year, and he’s doing exactly what a smart, team-first 20-year-old should do with the minutes he’s getting. The shooting will need to clean up. But the foundation is already there — and it’s a lot further along than people probably realize.
2. Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Atlanta Hawks
The Career Reinvention Nobody Saw Coming
By all accounts, Nickeil Alexander-Walker was supposed to be a role player.
A good one, sure. The kind every team wants — defend your position, knock down open threes, don’t mess anything up. That was the reputation.
And to be fair, that’s exactly who he was in Minnesota. When the Wolves picked him up in the Mike Conley deal back in 2023, he slid right into that 3-and-D role and did it about as cleanly as you could ask for — nine, maybe ten points a night, tough perimeter defense, showed up every single game. No drama, no drop-offs. You knew what you were getting.
The Timberwolves valued that, but the reality of roster building hit. With money tied up elsewhere — re-signing Naz Reid, bringing in Julius Randle — NAW became the odd man out.
So Atlanta signs him to a four-year, $62 million deal this summer, and the reaction was pretty straightforward. Solid pickup. Nice depth piece. A guy who can help you win some minutes off the bench.
Nobody — and I mean nobody — was talking about him as a potential 20-points-a-night guy.
And yet, that’s exactly what he’s turned into.
Seven Years In, and Only Getting Better
NAW's season has been genuinely stunning. He's scoring at a career-high clip, shooting 53 percent from the field on the season, and in March alone he's been operating at another level entirely — averaging 21.5 points while shooting 54.8 percent from the field and 44.4 percent from three. And on Monday night, in a win over Orlando that extended Atlanta's winning streak to ten games, he put up a career-high 41 points on 9-of-15 from three.
Forty-one points. Nine threes.
To understand why this is happening now, you have to understand where the shots are coming from. In Minnesota, the Wolves rebuilt his game entirely around off-ball movement and catch-and-shoot opportunities. He cut his pick-and-roll usage drastically, leaned into his 3-and-D identity, and became an extremely efficient role player.
But in Atlanta, something clicked — and it’s more than just taking more shots. It’s the type of shots and when they’re coming. He’s not just standing in the corner waiting anymore. He’s relocating, coming off movement, getting into the offense early, and creating more for himself. It’s a much more active version of the same player.
Part of it is the Trae Young trade, which reshuffled the offensive hierarchy and opened up opportunities that didn’t exist before. Part of it is playing alongside Jalen Johnson, who has quietly been one of the best players in the East this year and draws enough defensive attention to open real windows for guys around him.
He’s also the cousin of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, which has always been part of his story. They were high school teammates. They shared a room at their coach’s house. And for years, the comparison sat there as a reminder of how far the gap was. This season doesn’t close that gap, exactly. But it’s the first time NAW looks like a guy carving out his own lane instead of just being tied to someone else’s.
The Hawks are 37-31, sitting eighth in the East and fighting for positioning with their ten-game winning streak. And NAW has been right in the middle of that push.
However this season ends, this isn’t just a nice story anymore. NAW’s breakout has turned into one of the more legitimate and unexpected individual developments of the 2025-26 season.
3. Baylor Scheierman, Boston Celtics
A Small-Town Kid Making Believers Out of a Championship Rotation
Let's be honest about what the expectations were for Baylor Scheierman.
He was the 30th pick — last man in the first round — in 2024, drafted by a team that was already a championship roster. The Celtics had just won the title. They didn’t need saving. They didn’t need immediate help. They definitely didn’t need a rookie wing coming in and taking real minutes.
So the script was already written for him. Spend a year learning. Maybe bounce between the bench and the G League. Figure out the speed of the league. Earn trust slowly.
That’s how this usually goes for guys in his spot.
Nobody said anything about becoming a consistent rotation piece for a contender in Year 2 — and definitely not this quickly.
Scheierman grew up in Aurora, Nebraska — population about 4,000 — and his path definitely got tougher because of that. Nothing about it was fast-tracked. He played three sports in high school, was his team’s quarterback, and threw for a state-record 59 touchdowns. Then it was South Dakota State, which isn’t exactly a pipeline to the NBA. Then Creighton, where he finally started getting real national attention and turned into one of the most complete players in college basketball.
Every step of the way, he had to prove it a little more than the next guy.
And that usually doesn’t stop when you get to the NBA. If anything, it gets harder. This league is full of guys who were the best player in every gym they ever walked into, and a lot of them still can’t quite figure out where they fit once they get here.
This season, with Jayson Tatum out early recovering from an Achilles injury, there were real minutes sitting there for someone to take. And Scheierman didn’t just fill them — he made it hard for the Celtics to take them away.
He’s shooting 38 percent from three, 46 percent from the field overall, and more importantly, he’s playing the kind of clean, low-mistake basketball that coaches trust. He’s not overdribbling. He’s not forcing shots. He’s spacing correctly, making the extra pass, and really competing defensively.
Mazzulla calling him a “utility guy” says a lot. That’s not a throwaway label on a team like the Celtics.
He’s made starts when Tatum’s been out, and maybe more telling, he didn’t disappear when Tatum came back. That’s usually where young guys get squeezed out. Instead, Boston has had to actually think about where he fits, because he’s given them a real reason to keep him on the floor.
Go Ahead, Keep Doubting Him
The thing about Scheierman is that opposing benches consistently underestimate him. There's clear evidence of it, too — a moment earlier this season against Sacramento where players on the Kings' bench started heckling him as he set up for an open three. He drained it, looked back at them, and kept playing. It keeps happening. The funky haircut, the Nebraska roots, the mid-major pedigree — teams look at him and see a soft spot to attack.
And you can almost feel that mindset on the court. Defenders give him just a half-step too much space. Rotations are a beat late. He’s the guy teams are comfortable helping off of — until they realize later that he keeps burning them.
Mazzulla specifically praised the growth in his defensive awareness. And that’s kind of the perfect example of what he is right now — a guy making winning plays that don’t always show up in the box score but absolutely impact the result.
That’s the stuff that earns trust in a championship rotation. You don’t stick around on Boston’s bench without giving the coaching staff reasons to trust you.
Scheierman won’t put up 20. He’s not that guy. But he’s become the kind of dependable, low-maintenance rotation piece that championship teams tend to rely on. The Celtics are 45-23, they’ve got a real shot at making another deep run, and a 30th pick from a small town in Nebraska is part of why — even if most people outside of Boston haven’t caught on yet.
4. Jaylon Tyson, Cleveland Cavaliers
The Sophomore Nobody Saw Coming, on a Team Full of Stars
Jaylon Tyson's rookie season was almost invisible.
Forty-seven games, three starts, 3.6 points per night on a Cavaliers team that was the East's first seed and loaded with veteran talent. Nobody expected big contributions from the 20th pick. He got assigned to the G League multiple times. The expectation was that Cleveland had a developmental project on their hands.
And honestly, that’s what it looked like. He’d check in, run around, maybe get a couple looks, and that was about it. Nothing screamed breakout. Nothing even hinted at this.
He just put up 39 points against the Philadelphia 76ers. Seven three-pointers on nine attempts. That’s the kind of performance that forces you to go back and ask, “Wait… when did this happen?”
Tyson is having one of the more dramatic sophomore turnarounds in recent memory — and he's doing it quietly, behind a Cavaliers roster that has James Harden, Donovan Mitchell, and Darius Garland (before the trade) eating up most of the spotlight. He went from being an afterthought in a crowded rotation to being one of Cleveland's most important pieces.
And it’s not empty production either. He’s averaging 13.2 points and 5.1 rebounds while shooting nearly 46 percent from three — which ranks third in the entire NBA. On a playoff contender. In meaningful minutes.
And the more you watch him, the more it makes sense why Cleveland has started to trust him. He’s not just knocking down shots — he’s playing within the flow, making quick decisions, and not forcing anything outside of his role. It’s simple basketball, but it’s the kind that helps the team win in May, not just develop in March.
Those Four Stars Don’t Carry Over — You Earn It Here
Tyson was a four-star recruit who started at Texas, transferred to Texas Tech, transferred again to California, and finally had his breakout junior season at Cal — 19.6 points, 6.8 rebounds, 3.5 assists — before Cleveland drafted him. That kind of college journey — three schools, multiple fresh starts — either breaks a kid's confidence or hardens something in them. With Tyson, it seems like it built a mentality.
In late November, when the Cavaliers dropped three straight games, Tyson publicly called out the team's lack of effort as a second-year player. Some people questioned whether that was his place. Looking back, it fits with who he's become — a guy who takes his role seriously and holds himself and his teammates accountable regardless of his position on the depth chart.
Since that moment, he's averaged 15 points, 6 rebounds, and 2 assists while shooting 55 percent from the field and 49 percent from three. That's a different player.
His role has evolved throughout the season, too. He started as a fill-in starter while Cleveland dealt with injuries at the beginning of the year. Then the trade deadline reshuffled the roster, bringing in Harden and others, and Tyson settled into a reserve spot where he's become one of the league's best connectors in pick-and-rolls — setting screens, relocating, and immediately punishing any defense that loses track of him.
There's also the Most Improved Player conversation quietly building around him. He might not win it — it's a crowded field — but the fact that it's being mentioned at all for a 23-year-old on a playoff roster is its own kind of statement. A year ago, Cleveland was managing his development. This year, he's helping them manage their playoff push.
5. Tim Hardaway Jr., Denver Nuggets
From Vet Minimum to Playoff Swing Piece
Tim Hardaway Jr. signed a one-year, $3.63 million deal. Veteran minimum. A guy who'd bounced from the Knicks to the Mavericks to the Pistons over the last several years, never quite settling in anywhere. The Pistons experience was rough — 9.9 points a night, career-low efficiency, a player who looked like he was winding down.
And if you’re being honest, this felt like one of those “nice depth, we’ll see if he has anything left” type of signings. Not something you circle as a difference-maker.
Instead, he's been averaging 13.9 points in 27 minutes a game off the bench, shooting 41 percent from three on 188 attempts — which puts him tied for 13th in the league in made threes.
That's not a veteran minimum contract. That's a steal.
The Jokic Effect — But Also More Than That
The technical piece of why this is working starts with Nikola Jokic. Everything is easier when the center of your offense commands so much defensive attention that open threes just keep showing up. Hardaway isn't out there dancing into pull-ups — he’s catching, rising, and letting it go without hesitation.
And that matters. Because there’s a difference between being open… and being ready.
Coach David Adelman has said publicly that he'd love to see Hardaway launch 19 threes on a given night if the looks are there. That’s the kind of green light shooters dream about — and he’s actually taking advantage of it.
But it’s not just Jokic spoon-feeding him looks. What’s stood out is how quickly Hardaway can flip a possession. One dribble, quick trigger, back-to-back threes — suddenly a five-point game is 11. Denver hasn’t really had that kind of instant offense off the bench in a while.
Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.