Seahawks-Patriots: Revisiting the Infamous Goal-Line Call

After years of waiting, the Seahawks are finally back in the Super Bowl.

For their fans, it should be nothing but celebration. Another shot. Another chance. Proof that this era of Seattle football wasn’t a one‑off, that all those years in between weren’t wasted.

And it probably still is a fantastic moment — except, of course, for one unavoidable detail.

The opponent is the same one they faced the last time they were here.

So instead of two clean weeks of hype, Seahawks fans have spent this Super Bowl buildup reliving the play. The one where everyone seems to agree, Marshawn Lynch should've gotten the ball.

And here’s the thing: the longer this play lives, the worse our conversations about it have gotten. The debate has been flattened into a lazy coin flip — “run it, dummy” versus “actually, passing was smart.” Both sides grab their favorite talking point and stop there.

But Super Bowl XLIX wasn’t decided by a generic pass-versus-run debate. It was decided by a very specific pass, in a very specific situation, against a defense that was ready for it.

The Final Drive, In Real Time

The Seahawks don’t get to the 1-yard line without one of the wildest plays in Super Bowl history.

Seattle trails 28–24 late and is staring down a desperate third-and-long near midfield. Russell Wilson launches a deep ball down the left sideline intended for Jermaine Kearse. Malcolm Butler actually makes a great recovery, getting his hand in to deflect what should’ve been a game-changing incompletion.

Instead, the ball ricochets off Kearse’s arm, pops straight up, and somehow falls back down onto his chest as he’s stumbling to the ground. It’s the kind of bounce that only happens in Super Bowls — right up there with Edleman's fingertip catch in the 28-3 comeback.

That miracle bobble puts Seattle at New England’s 5-yard line with 1:06 left. First-and-goal.

On first-and-goal at the 5, Marshawn Lynch runs left and gets four yards, down to the 1. The clock keeps rolling. No immediate timeout despite having one in their back pocket. The Seahawks are clearly trying to keep New England from getting the ball back with time — probably the right lane of thinking with number 12 on the other sideline.

Then, with 0:26 left, it’s second-and-goal from the 1. Russell Wilson takes the snap and fires a quick slant toward Ricardo Lockette. Malcolm Butler jumps it, picks it off at the goal line, and the game is effectively over.

The Clock Was The Third Opponent

If you want to understand the decision, you have to start with the timeout situation — and this is the part that usually gets glossed over. Yes, the clock mattered. But having that timeout completely changed the math.

Seattle wasn’t operating in panic mode yet. They still had flexibility. The old-school football answer would’ve been simple: run it on second down. If you don’t score, call timeout immediately. Now you’re staring at third down with roughly 20 seconds left and the entire playbook still open.

From there, you can do exactly what Seattle was trying to accomplish on second down anyway — throw a quick, low-risk pass on third that’s either incomplete or a game-winning touchdown. If it hits, you win. If it doesn’t, the clock stops, and you still get one last shot to hand it to Marshawn Lynch on fourth down with the Super Bowl on the line.

That’s the key distinction that gets lost. Passing itself wasn’t the issue. Sequencing was.

Instead, Pete Carroll tried to flip the order. He gambled that putting the pass on second down would catch Bill Belichick and the Patriots leaning run. Lynch had just ripped off four yards on first down, and the defense had every reason to expect more of the same.

The pass should’ve been the break-glass option if the run failed, not the first swing. By choosing to lead with it, Seattle put the entire game on a single play with no safety net.

If You’re Going To Throw It, That Can’t Be The Throw

Now, even if Seattle wanted to pass on second down, the slant into traffic is about the worst version of “safe” you could’ve picked against that defense — especially with that personnel on the field.

This isn’t a “slants are bad” rant. Slants are great. They’re staples for a reason. But slants at the goal line are a completely different animal. The field is compressed, the middle is clogged, and corners are playing inside leverage knowing any throw to the outside is going to have to go over them or through them.

Seattle tried to manufacture separation with a pick concept, which makes sense on paper. The problem was who was involved. Brandon Browner — a big, physical corner who knew Seattle’s tendencies — was lined up on the pick man. He didn’t finesse it. He blew it up. Browner jammed the route so hard at the line of scrimmage that Malcolm Butler suddenly had a free runway to the ball.

From there, it turned into a footrace. And Butler was the only one who knew the race had started. He was breaking downhill the moment Wilson let it go, and he got to the spot first.

This decision has always bothered me more than just passing in that spot. Not only do I think it was the wrong moment to put the ball in the air, I think the play itself was dead before the snap. Once Browner was walked up and pressing, that slant had no escape hatch — and Seattle still ran it instead of checking into something that at least gave them a softer landing.

Marshawn’s Side Of It: "Dumbest Call in Football History"

Lynch has said he expected to get the ball at the 1-yard line, and that expectation wasn’t unreasonable or emotional. It was common sense. You have a legendary short-yardage runner, a guy whose entire reputation was built on turning chaos into certainty, and you’re standing one yard away from a championship. The instinct isn’t complicated. You put it in his hands and live with whatever happens next.

Instead, Lynch talked about how he thought Carroll took that all away:

I usually don’t take my helmet off, but, you know, I take my helmet off and I go right to Pete’s face, and I’m talking about — I hit him with the biggest [imitates laughing in his face]... That’s a once-in-a-lifetime situation, you know? You took a dream away. You took a moment away. You take a dynasty away. You take away all that. You put us in the history books as the dumbest call in football history.

One Yard Turned Into A Lifetime of Debating

Do I think it was the single worst call ever made? No. Football’s had plenty of disasters, blown coverages, and coaching malpractice to go around.

But given the context — the opponent, the clock, the timeout in their pocket, the running back standing next to the quarterback — it’s hard to come up with many gaffs that were more self-inflicted.

This wasn’t about being bold. It wasn’t about being analytical. It was about trying to be one step ahead when you didn’t actually need to be. Seattle had leverage. They had time. They had downs. And they had Marshawn Lynch.

Sometimes the obvious answer is obvious for a reason. Not because it’s safe. Not because it’s old-school. But because it's the way that has consistently worked when everything is on the line.

Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.