Hunter Tierney Nov 21, 2026 10 min read

Nobody Tackling, Nobody Covering: Inside the Patriots’ Slide

Oct 5, 2025; Orchard Park, New York, USA; New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel during the first half at Highmark Stadium.
New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel. | Mark Konezny-Imagn Images

Jahmyr Gibbs is going to live rent-free in a lot of Patriots fans' heads this week, and honestly, that's fair. He ran for 153 yards and two touchdowns in Munich, caught seven passes for another 99, and spent a Sunday morning making New England's defense look like they were still on Boston time.

But Detroit's 35-10 win wasn't some weird one-off in a soccer stadium. It was the fourth straight week this defense looked nothing like the unit that helped carry this team to a Super Bowl in February. And it happened on the same morning Drake Maye's ankle got caught under Aidan Hutchinson on the opening drive.

That combination is the whole problem. The Patriots can survive a bad defensive stretch when Maye's healthy and slinging it. They can survive a backup quarterback if the defense is what it was last year. They can't survive both, and right now they've got both.

It Started in Chicago

If you want to pin down when this went sideways, circle October 22nd at Soldier Field.

Through the first six games, the Patriots were giving up 18.8 points a game. That's the exact number last year's defense allowed on the way to being 14-3. There were ugly moments, sure. That 35-6 faceplant in Jacksonville still stings. But the unit itself mostly looked like the one we got used to in 2025.

Then came Thursday night in Chicago. Caleb Williams threw for 308 yards, Luther Burden III went for 130, and the Patriots missed a season-high 14 tackles in a 30-24 loss. Marcus Jones missed five by himself, a career high. At the time, it read like a short-week stinker.

It wasn't. New England went to Miami and fell behind 13-3 at halftime against a one-win Dolphins team quarterbacked by Malik Willis before Maye bailed them out. Then Green Bay hung 45 on them at Gillette, the most points anyone's ever scored in that building, with Jordan Love going 23-of-29 for 372 yards and three touchdowns. Then Munich.

Over those four games, the Patriots have allowed 129 points. That's 32.3 a game, nearly double what they were giving up a month earlier. The last two alone produced 80 points and 972 yards, the most the franchise has allowed over a two-game span since 1994.

Detroit's 494 yards were the most this defense has given up in a regulation game since the Eagles in Super Bowl LII, which is a sentence nobody in New England needed to read again.

Gibbs Found a New Leak

Detroit Lions running back Jahmyr Gibbs celebrates a touchdown against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers with wide receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown during the first half at Ford Field in Detroit on Monday, Oct. 20, 2025.
Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Here's what surprised me going back through the numbers: the run defense wasn't really the problem in this stretch until Sunday.

New England held Chicago, Miami, and Green Bay all well below zero in EPA per rush. Kaleb Johnson had 68 yards on 14 carries for the Packers. Love didn't need him anyway. He had seven completions of 28 yards or more. The bleeding for the last month has come through the air. New England ranks 31st in pass EPA allowed over the last four games after sitting 13th through the first six, and their explosive pass rate allowed jumped from 14.1% to 19.6%.

So Gibbs didn't expose a run defense that had been quietly falling apart. He opened a second leak in a boat that was already sinking.

And the way he did it should bug Zak Kuhr. Detroit ran outside zone on half their designed runs, and Gibbs kept finding the cutback. The Patriots' edges spilled plays and vacated their gaps, and then Cory Durden, DaQuan Jones, and Joshua Farmer got moved off the point of attack inside. New England gave up 57 rushing yards before contact, their worst of the season. Gibbs averaged 7.0 a carry.

Then there's the tackling, which has been shaky all year. The Patriots have hit double digits in missed tackles twice in the last four games — 14 in Chicago, 10 in Munich— and the 6.6 yards they allow after a missed tackle ranks 29th. Craig Woodson took a bad angle on Amon-Ra St. Brown's 56-yard touchdown, and Christian Gonzalez slipped on the same play. On St. Brown's second score, he dragged a handful of Patriots into the end zone with him.

Kevin Byard didn't hold back after the game:

They played harder than us today.

Not a lot of wiggle room in that one.

The Offense Owns Some of This

To be fair to the defense, they haven't been getting much help.

New England's offense turned it over 19 times through nine games, tied for the most in the league — and opponents turned those giveaways into 71 points. That's more than a third of everything the Patriots allowed through Week 9, and it's already more than the 52 points off turnovers they gave up in all of 2025. Green Bay scored 21 points off four turnovers by themselves.

Munich had a whole other issue to deal with. Once Maye went down, Tommy DeVito's offense went three-and-out on six of their 10 drives. The defense was on the field for 68 plays and more than 33 minutes. Nobody tackles well in the fourth quarter when you're out there that much.

But that excuse only stretches so far. Love's deep shots didn't need a short field. And Detroit's first two drives were a six-play, 70-yard touchdown and an 11-play, 97-yard touchdown. The second one came right after a punt pinned the Lions at their own 3, with Detroit up just 7-3. That's not fatigue or a bad bounce. That's a defense getting whipped on a clean slate.

What's Actually Different

So what changed from last year? A few things, and not all of them get fixed over a bye week.

Start with the pass rush, or what's left of it. Harold Landry led last year's team with 8.5 sacks and has spent this entire season on the PUP list with knee problems. Vrabel said earlier this month he's working hard and "just isn't ready to go yet." K'Lavon Chaisson, last year's No. 2 sack guy, left in free agency. Dre'Mont Jones is playing in a shoulder harness. Rookie Gabe Jacas has been one of the few guys trending up, but that's a lot to put on a rookie.

It shows. New England's pressure rate has dropped from 39.6% last season to 32.0%, which ranks 26th. The four-man rush ranks 20th in pressure rate, so Kuhr has had to manufacture heat with blitzes and man coverage. That works until offenses solve it, and the NFC North did. In the Bears, Packers, and Lions games, they all averaged +0.69 EPA per dropback against the blitz. When New England drops into zone instead, it's worse: the Patriots are dead last in the league in EPA allowed in zone coverage, and they've played zone almost two-thirds of the time.

The secondary hasn't had a full deck either. Carlton Davis is out with a knee injury, so Charles Woods is starting outside again. And Gonzalez, fresh off a four-year, $135 million extension, is in the worst two-week stretch of his career. Matthew Golden caught all 10 of his targets for 164 yards, mostly with Gonzalez in coverage, and St. Brown beat him on both of his touchdowns in Munich.

Then there's the stuff nobody likes talking about. "Effort and finish" are supposed to be non-negotiable in Vrabel's program, and it's literally posted at Gillette. After Munich, Byard said it felt like "a slap in the face that we let them play harder." Milton Williams said it was probably the worst game he's ever played.

When your own veterans are saying that out loud, the film's probably saying it louder.

No Margin Left With DeVito

Dec 15, 2024; Glendale, Arizona, USA; New England Patriots cornerback Christian Gonzalez (0) against the Arizona Cardinals at State Farm Stadium.
Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

All of that would be a problem in any season. This season, it's imperative for them to even make it to the postseason.

Maye's not coming back anytime soon. He fractured his right ankle, and Vrabel said Monday he "wouldn't imagine him being available" coming out of the bye. Byard went on WEEI and basically said the quiet part out loud:

At the end of the day, our quarterback's out. He's probably going to be out for the rest of the season. And the reality of the situation is, is that we're going to have to get behind Tommy Two Chains at the end of the day. And you know, we're all going to have to do more, myself included. Everybody has to play better around our quarterback. I mean, this is honestly before Drake was injured as well. But we got to play better around our quarterback. We got two choices: we can rally behind this guy or we can pack it up. I mean, that's just where we're at right now in the season.

Tommy Two Chains went 12-of-24 for 81 yards in Munich. He was pressured on almost half his dropbacks behind a line missing both starting guards, and he's throwing to a receiver room where A.J. Brown just hurt his hamstring. Vrabel says he has "a lot of confidence in Tommy," and he should say that. But nobody's expecting DeVito to win shootouts.

That means the Patriots need the 2025 formula back. Last year's defense finished top 10 in total yards, rushing yards, and passing yards allowed, then gave up just 3.1 yards a carry during the playoff run.

Win 20-17. Make the other quarterback earn every yard. Take the ball away. That's the only version of this team that wins with a backup under center.

The schedule isn't doing them any favors. After the 1-8 Chargers on Nov. 29th, it's Buffalo, Minnesota, at Kansas City, and Denver, four teams with a combined 29-7 record. The Jets and Dolphins are in there too, and at 5-5, New England probably needs to win most of what's left.

Some of this is fixable in a week. Tackling angles, communication in zone, edges setting the edge instead of spilling everything outside: that's coachable, and Vrabel has a bye to coach it. What he doesn't have is a Landry-level rusher walking through the door, or Davis back on the outside.

All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.


Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.

Explore by Topic