Hunter Tierney Nov 19, 2026 5 min read

Cowboys Put Up 40 and Still Brought a Knife to a Shootout

Nov 3, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys defensive end Marshawn Kneeland (94) celebrates with defensive end Sam Williams (54) after recovering a blocked punt for a touchdown against the Arizona Cardinals in the first half at AT&T Stadium.
Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

Dak Prescott threw five touchdown passes Sunday, and somehow the Cowboys still needed one more.

George Pickens caught three of them — piling up 145 receiving yards — and gave Dallas the kind of afternoon they desperately needed from him. The Cowboys scored 40 points at home. They lost 46-40 anyway.

Sure, there’s plenty to pick apart on offense. Prescott threw an interception, and 21 of Dallas’ points came in the fourth quarter after they'd fallen behind 38-19. This wasn’t four quarters of perfect football.

But the comeback pulled the Cowboys within six with 3:42 left. The defense had a chance to get Prescott the ball back with a real shot to win.

Nineteen seconds later, Christian McCaffrey scored again.

And that’s the problem Dallas keeps running into: The offense can fight their way back into a game, but somebody has to stop giving the other team a shovel.

How Bad Are We Talking?

San Francisco finished with 584 yards, the most Dallas has ever allowed at home. Their 9.42 yards per play ranked second among all games against the Cowboys, behind Denver’s 9.54 in 1998. That’s damn near a first down every time the ball was snapped.

San Francisco’s +0.48 EPA per play was the NFL’s best offensive performance in a game this season.

The frustrating part is that Dallas actually got to Brock Purdy. The Cowboys sacked him five times after San Francisco had allowed eight sacks coming into the night. That should’ve given the defense something to build on. Instead, those negative plays barely mattered because of everything that happened in between.

McCaffrey finished with 223 yards from scrimmage and three touchdowns. He needed just four catches to pile up 161 receiving yards. Dallas let a running back have a huge receiving day without even making him particularly busy.

The Problems Are Coming From Every Direction

McCaffrey’s first receiving touchdown went 74 yards, but it started with him doing the unglamorous work: protecting Purdy. When Purdy escaped the pocket, McCaffrey slipped into space and became the outlet. Dallas couldn’t finish the rush, and once the play broke down, nobody accounted for the back.

Give Purdy credit. Keeping that play alive took some doing. But a defense can’t get that close to ending a possession and then completely lose track of someone like McCaffrey.

Deebo Samuel’s 70-yard reverse exposed a completely different problem. Kaelon Black took the pitch to the right, and Kyle Juszczyk’s motion pulled all the attention that way. Samuel got the ball coming back left with open field in front of him.

Then came the matchup everybody’s understandably stuck on: 37-year-old Von Miller covering McCaffrey with no deep safety behind him.

Dallas called Cover 0, and Miller was responsible for picking up the back if he released. Miller said afterward that he expected an outside route:

I was too quick outside.

I appreciate him owning it. His technique mattered. But in no world should future Hall-of-Famer Von Miller — who, even in his prime, wouldn't have been able to stay with McCaffrey — be asked to survive that matchup with nobody behind him. You can understand wanting pressure in that situation, but that wasn't the way to do it.

A Different Play-Caller, the Same Problems to Fix

Aug 22, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys head coach Brian Schottenheimer gives directions prior to the game against the Atlanta Falcons at AT&T Stadium.
Andrew Dieb-Imagn Images

The Cowboys made a change Wednesday, handing defensive play-calling to Mike Pettine while Christian Parker keeps the coordinator title.

Pettine has plenty to clean up. Dallas ranks last in total defense and rushing defense, along with 30th in scoring defense. This problem is much bigger than one rough afternoon against Kyle Shanahan.

The personnel situation isn’t getting any easier, either. DaRon Bland left Sunday’s game with an ankle injury and will miss more time. But injuries don’t explain every blown assignment or missed tackle.

Pettine can change the calls. The players still have to recognize the play, keep outside leverage, and actually get somebody on the ground.

After Sunday’s loss, Brian Schottenheimer said:

At the end of the day, we didn't score enough points to win.

He’s technically right, but that sucks to hear when your quarterback threw five touchdowns. Before Dallas starts trying to figure out where the sixth one should’ve come from, they need a defense that can make five enough.

All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.


Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.

Explore by Topic