Burrow Can Do Everything Right and Still Lose to the Steelers
Joe Burrow completed his first 14 passes against Pittsburgh in September. He threw three touchdowns, didn’t toss an interception, and was sacked just once.
The Bengals still lost.
That pretty much tells you what Sunday night’s rematch is about. Cincinnati knows they can move the ball against Pittsburgh. The bigger challenge is finishing the game without giving the Steelers enough extra chances to make all that good quarterback play irrelevant.
Both teams come into Week 10 at 6–2, riding four-game winning streaks and sitting atop the AFC North. Cleveland’s close behind at 5–4, with Baltimore at 4–5. There’s a lot of football left, but somebody’s leaving Paycor Stadium with the division lead Sunday night.
Kickoff is 8:20 p.m. ET on NBC and Peacock, and Cincinnati will be wearing their White Bengal uniforms. Nobody's going to need any help getting fired up for this one.
Make This a Jaylen Warren Game
Aaron Rodgers is the name on the marquee. Jaylen Warren might be the guy who decides whether Pittsburgh gets to play the kind of game they want.
Warren’s averaging 5.92 yards per carry, and he already gave Cincinnati 127 rushing yards and another 49 receiving yards in the first meeting. He’s coming off 143 rushing yards against Cleveland before Pittsburgh’s bye. This isn’t a matchup where the Steelers need to dream up some elaborate way to help their quarterback. They’ve already got one.
The numbers make the plan pretty clear. Pittsburgh's first in rushing EPA and 26th in passing. Warren’s averaging 6.12 yards on gap and man runs, and Cincinnati’s allowing running backs 5.36 yards per carry on those concepts.
That’s an invitation to get the blockers moving, make Cincinnati’s linebackers fight through traffic, and give Warren a chance to turn an ordinary crease into a big play.
There’s one pretty significant complication, though: Dexter Lawrence. He had two third-down sacks late in the first meeting and helped force Pittsburgh to settle for field goals. Center Zach Frazier and the interior line have to keep Lawrence from blowing up the play before Warren even gets a chance to make something happen.
And staying on schedule doesn’t mean running Warren into a wall twice and asking Rodgers to save the offense on third-and-nine. It means mixing in Warren’s carries with quick throws and play-action while Cincinnati still has to respect everything else.
Burrow Doesn’t Need Many Openings
Cincinnati’s passing game is good enough that Pittsburgh can do a lot right and still give up 27 points. We’ve already seen that happen.
Burrow leads the league with 23 touchdown passes, a 74% completion rate, and a 114.8 passer rating. The Bengals just beat Atlanta 34–17 in Madrid, scoring touchdowns on their first three possessions. They’re averaging 30 points a gamethis season.
The interesting part is how they’re creating the big plays. This isn’t Burrow chucking deep balls every other snap. Fantasy Points has just 8.7% of Cincinnati’s attempts charted as deep throws, but the Bengals rank first in efficiency on those passes and second on intermediate throws. They’re picking their spots and making those throws count.
Just look at Ja’Marr Chase’s 47-yard touchdown in Madrid. Atlanta had him in man coverage with the safety playing shallow, and Cincinnati attacked it with a double move to the post. A third-and-two turned into a touchdown because the Bengals saw a chance to do more than just move the chains.
That’s the balance Pittsburgh has to find. Crowd the short stuff too aggressively, and Chase can get behind you. Give him extra attention and Tee Higgins gets more room. Higgins already has 758 receiving yards and six touchdowns. Mike Gesicki has six touchdown catches, too, including the fourth-down score that put Cincinnati ahead in the first matchup.
The Steelers need pressure without constantly pulling extra bodies out of coverage. T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Cameron Heyward have to make Cincinnati’s protection work while the secondary keeps those intermediate completions from turning into something bigger.
Familiar Doesn’t Mean Predictable
There’s something useful about playing a team you already know, especially after flying home from Spain. Cincinnati knows Pittsburgh’s personnel, and that September tape gives both staffs a real starting point.
But this is also Mike McCarthy’s first season coaching Pittsburgh, with Patrick Graham running the defense. The problems up front might look familiar, but Pittsburgh has more ways to dress them up.
That puts more weight on the little things: moving a receiver before the snap, showing the same formation and running a different route out of it, or disguising which defender’s coming.
Cincinnati’s two-tight-end packages are worth watching. Fantasy Points has the Bengals using them on 40.8% of their plays, with the league’s second-best efficiency from that grouping. Pittsburgh ranks 25th against it. So when Cincinnati puts two tight ends on the field, Pittsburgh can’t just assume Burrow’s handing the ball off.
Stop Giving Away the Fourth Quarter
The first meeting turned on Cincinnati giving Pittsburgh possessions out of the blue.
A roughing-the-punter penalty extended one Steelers drive. A muffed punt brought another one back to life. Those mistakes turned into 10 Pittsburgh points. Then Harmon knocked the ball out of Burrow’s hands with Cincinnati driving in the last minute.
That’s why the turnover conversation matters beyond the usual “take care of the football” stuff. These teams have already played a three-point game where special teams and one late defensive play ruined an excellent passing performance.
Pittsburgh's plus-five in turnover differential; Cincinnati is plus-two. The Steelers also haven’t allowed a second-half touchdown in five games. Cincinnati shouldn’t count on getting unlimited chances to make up for an empty possession late.
Pittsburgh has their own finishing problem, though. The Steelers have scored touchdowns on half of their red-zone trips, while Cincinnati’s defense has allowed touchdowns on just 42.9% of opponents’ visits. Moving the ball and settling for field goals could keep Pittsburgh close without ever putting Cincinnati under enough pressure.
Rodgers acknowledged the bigger concern Wednesday:
When you win, sometimes you can gloss over some areas that need improvement.
Sunday would be a pretty inconvenient time to find out those areas still need work.
Three Keys
1. Win the early downs. Pittsburgh needs Warren to keep things manageable. Cincinnati needs enough quick, efficient offense to keep Watt and Highsmith from turning every snap into a pass-rush drill.
2. Make the explosive plays difficult. Pittsburgh can live with giving up completions underneath. Letting Chase or Higgins score because somebody chased the wrong route? That’s a much bigger problem.
3. Finish the possession. Catch the punt. Get off the field after forcing fourth down. Turn red-zone chances into touchdowns. September gave us a pretty clear reminder of what happens when you don’t.
Prediction: Bengals 30, Steelers 20. Warren should keep Pittsburgh in the game, but I trust Cincinnati’s passing game to put together the more complete game at home.
Burrow’s already shown he can play well against this defense. This time, Cincinnati needs to let that be enough.
All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.
Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.