Hunter Tierney May 21, 2025 10 min read

Hard Fouls, Hard Truths: Clark and Reese Reignite Rivalry

Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese (5) reacts to a flagrant foul from Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark (22) on Saturday, May 17, 2025, during a game between the Indiana Fever and the Chicago Sky at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis. The Indiana Fever defeated the Chicago Sky, 93-58.
Credit: Grace Smith/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

It didn’t even take a full three quarters for the latest chapter in the Caitlin Clark vs. Angel Reese saga to go from simmer to sizzle. From the moment both players checked into the season opener between the Indiana Fever and Chicago Sky, you could feel the tension in the building — not just from the fans, but from the players themselves.

By the time the third quarter rolled around, that tension boiled over. On a routine-looking play, Reese pushed a Fever player when fighting for a rebound, got position, and looked to have an easy finish. Clark, as she's done countless times before, rotated over hard, swiped with force, and committed a foul instead of allowing two easy points. It didn't look like much at the moment, but ended up getting called for a flagrant.

Reese hit the deck, popped up with some heat, and had to be held back. It wasn’t anything outlandish — no punches thrown or ejections — but it was enough to get 17,000 fans in Indy up out of their seats and millions more buzzing online. Social media lit up instantly with highlight clips, slow-mo replays, and hot takes flying from everyone.

The Fever went on to win in a blowout, 93–58, but you wouldn’t know it from the headlines. Because, honestly, the scoreboard felt like a side note. The real story was the moment. It wasn’t just about one foul or one shove — it was about what it represented. Two of the most popular, most polarizing, and most competitive young stars in the game going toe-to-toe, again, in a league that’s betting big on their firepower to carry it into the future.

From Baton Rouge and Iowa City to Chicago and Indiana

In one of the iconic moments of last year's NCAA women's tournament, Angel Reese of LSU points to her ring finger as Iowa's Caitlin Clark can only watch during the national championship game. LSU defeated Iowa 102 85.
Credit: Zach Boyden-Holmes / USA TODAY NETWORK

Before either of them stepped onto a WNBA court, Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese had already become two of the most recognizable faces in the sport.

Back in 2023, when Reese and LSU toppled Clark’s Iowa squad in the national title game, the ratings shattered every expectation. That 102–85 win pulled in nearly 10 million viewers, peaking at 12.6 million. That’s not just impressive for women’s basketball — that’s flat-out impressive, period. A year later, the rematch in the 2024 Elite Eight wasn’t just hyped — it delivered. This time Clark got her revenge, Iowa advanced, and the game drew 12.3 million on ESPN, outdrawing every NBA game that week.

It wasn’t just the wins and losses that grabbed attention, either. It was the style. Clark with her deep pull-ups and incredible passing. Reese with her energy, physicality, and dominant rebounding presence. They were polar opposites in how they played, but identical in how they competed — loud, intense, and unapologetically confident.

So by the time the 2024 WNBA Draft rolled around, it wasn’t just obvious that Clark was going No. 1 and Reese would land somewhere in the first round — it felt like destiny that they’d end up in opposing markets. Clark landed in Indiana, the top pick on a Fever team desperate for a spark. Reese went to Chicago, where her game, energy, and marketability were a perfect fit for the Sky. The rivalry wasn’t slowing down — it was just getting started on a bigger stage.

Rookie Seasons That Lived Up to the Hype

Most rookies need some time to adjust after college — to the speed, the physicality, the mental grind of the pro game. Not Caitlin Clark. She walked into the WNBA with a huge spotlight on her back and managed to deliver right out of the gate.

Clark put together one of the most complete rookie seasons we’ve seen in years. She wasn’t just a scorer — though she poured in nearly 20 a night — she ran Indiana’s offense like a seasoned vet.

She set the WNBA rookie record for assists in a season with 337, broke the single-game rookie assist record with 19, and still managed to hit logo threes and run pick-and-rolls with ease. That’s not normal. That’s special.

And Reese? She built her rookie campaign around relentlessness. Every single night, she was hitting the boards like the game depended on it. She racked up 446 rebounds — the most ever by a rookie — and averaged 13.1 per game. She dropped 26 double-doubles and went on a tear with 15 in a row, which was another rookie record.

Her offense came along as the season progressed, with that 27-point performance in Seattle being her breakout scoring game. For her efforts, she took home Rookie of the Month in June and kept her foot on the gas from there.

Now, neither the Fever nor the Sky made deep playoff runs, but that didn’t stop people from tuning in. Fever-Sky games consistently pulled in over 1.2 million viewers, and ticket prices on the resale market went through the roof.

Opening‑Night Flashpoint

May 17, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark (22) fouls Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese (5) in the second half at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images
Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images

Fast-forward to May 17, 2025, and the opening game of the season between Indiana and Chicago already had that must-watch energy. The Fever had built a steady lead behind strong play from Caitlin Clark and Aliyah Boston, and the Sky were trying to claw their way back in when things got chippy in the third quarter.

Angel Reese, who had been battling on the boards all game, got tangled up in a physical sequence in the paint. She pushed off slightly to gain space — enough to clear out Aliyah Boston — and found herself with a lane to the hoop. But Clark slid over to stop the play and committed a hard foul across Reese’s arms and back. It was the kind of take foul you see a dozen times a night, but this one had a little extra juice.

Reese hit the floor hard. The crowd reacted instantly. Clark extended her arm after the contact in a way that, on replay, showed more than just a slap on the ball. Officials reviewed it and upgraded the play to a flagrant-1, citing “wind-up, impact, and follow-through.” And just like that, what could’ve been a routine foul became the biggest talking point in sports that weekend.

Reese jumped up, clearly upset, and had words for Clark — the kind that earned her a technical. Boston stepped in to cool things off but got hit with a tech of her own for her part in the scrum.

Emotions were high, the energy was wild, and fans in the building were eating it up. On the very next few possessions, the Fever went on a 9-0 run that basically shut the door on any Sky comeback hopes.

Clark finished with a statement triple-double: 20 points, 10 assists, 10 rebounds, and four blocks. Reese, despite the heated moment, pulled down a game-high 17 boards and added 12 points of her own. It was physical, it was personal, and it was everything fans had been waiting for since the rivalry first took shape in college. The fact that it ended in a flagrant foul only made it that much more real. 

Trash Talk, Techs, and the Thin Line Between Passion and Hate

In just about any other game, that foul wouldn't have been worth a short segment on SportsCenter. But not with these two. What happened between Clark and Reese on the court had already stirred up all kinds of buzz, but what came after — that took things to another level, and not in a good way.

Less than a day after the game, the WNBA announced it was looking into reports that Angel Reese was targeted with hateful comments from the stands during the game, including racist language. It wasn’t just a Twitter rumor — multiple fan videos and social posts raised red flags, and it was enough for the league to open an official investigation.

The WNBA has been very public about its “No Space for Hate” initiative, and this moment immediately tested that stance. League officials confirmed they were reviewing audio and security footage to identify the source of the comments.

Clark, when asked about it, said she didn’t hear anything specific during the game, but she didn’t hesitate to say that stuff has no place in basketball — or anywhere else. Fever head coach Stephanie White said the same, calling on fans and arena staff to step up and report that behavior when they see or hear it.

Why This Rivalry Works — and Why It’s Healthy

May 17, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark (22) passes around Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese (5) on Saturday, May 17, 2025, during a game between the Indiana Fever and the Chicago Sky at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis. The Indiana Fever defeated the Chicago Sky, 93-58.
Credit: Grace Smith-IndyStar via Imagn Images

Some corners of social media try to paint the Clark vs. Reese rivalry in a really poor light, but at the end of the day, this is just really entertaining basketball. The contrast in style is what makes it fun. It’s flashy finesse versus raw power. It’s logo threes versus second-chance buckets. And that kind of contrast draws eyeballs.

It also challenges both players to keep evolving. Clark, for her part, has had to learn how to handle constant pressure and bigger defenders. Teams throw size at her, so her passing has had to be sharper — and it is. She’s learned how to use those aggressive closeouts to her advantage, dishing out quick hits when the defense collapses. That’s growth.

Reese has had to adapt too, but it’s fair to say her next step is more important now than ever. She’s always going to own the boards — nobody questions that. But for this rivalry to really reach that Bird-Magic level that the league wants, she’s going to have to keep adding layers to her offensive game. Right now, Indiana — and most of the league, honestly — is willing to sag off her and live with mid-range jumpers. She’s improved in the face-up area, sure, but if she wants to be that player, she’s going to have to stretch the floor more and become a more reliable scorer outside the paint.

It’s not a knock — it’s just reality. Clark is already drawing MVP buzz. Reese is still seen more as a disruptor and enforcer. But if she can start putting up 20-point nights consistently and make defenses respect her jumper? Then we’re talking about a rivalry that could really define the league's future.

Explore by Topic