Lila PrescottNov 20, 2026 5 min read

Texas Judicial Nominee Dodges Senator on Whether Trump Can Seek a Third Term

James P. Sullivan Confirmation Hearing
James P. Sullivan. | U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee

A Senate Judiciary Committee hearing took an awkward turn Wednesday when one of President Donald Trump's judicial nominees struggled to describe the 22nd Amendment and then declined to say whether Trump can run for a third term. James P. Sullivan, a Texas Supreme Court justice who lost his reelection bid earlier this month, faced questions from Sen. Chris Coons, a Delaware Democrat, during a confirmation hearing for a federal judgeship in Texas.

A Shaky Start on the Amendment

Coons began by asking Sullivan what the 22nd Amendment provides. Sullivan hesitated and said the text is not always at the front of his mind, and Coons stepped in with the amendment's opening words. Sullivan then said that no person should be elected more than twice to the office of the president.

James P. Sullivan.
James P. Sullivan. | Texas Courts

The amendment states that "no person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice." Coons noted that the limit came after Franklin D. Roosevelt won four terms, and Sullivan also pointed to Roosevelt when discussing the amendment's origins.

Coons also asked whether Trump has been elected president twice. Sullivan responded that Trump was certified the winner in 2016 and 2024.

Sullivan Declines to Weigh In on 2028

The exchange shifted when Coons asked whether Trump could run again in 2028. As a district court nominee, Sullivan said, offering an opinion "would be a violation, I believe, of Canon 5." He cited judicial ethics rules that bar judges from weighing in on political controversies.

Sullivan added that the issue remains the subject of ongoing political debate and said he would look to the amendment's text and its original public meaning.

Coons called the answer very disappointing. He said the amendment's language is clear and that he could respect a refusal to answer on a legal question that is truly unsettled, but not on this one. Coons also argued that the question is unresolved only in the mind of the president, who has said he might run for a third time.

Trump's Own Comments on a Third Term

President Trump threatens to double auto tariffs on Canada to 50%. | The White House
The White House

Trump has floated a third term at various points since returning to office. On Aug. 12, he said he would love to run again but acknowledged that the law is very strong on term limits. At an Oct. 22 rally in Sioux City, Iowa, he said he believed the law prohibits a third term, calling the relevant constitutional language concise with little room for interpretation.

Kennedy Presses on the Eighth Amendment

Sullivan faced tough questioning from a Republican as well. Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana challenged his reading of the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment as Sullivan struggled to connect his originalist philosophy with Supreme Court precedent. Kennedy told him, "You're talking in circles, judge."

Sen. John Kennedy during a press conference in 2022.
Sen. John Kennedy during a press conference in 2022. | U.S. Army

The hearing drew quick reactions online. Anti-disinformation activist Jim Stewartson called it one of the most embarrassing things he had ever seen, while journalist Aaron Rupar wrote that Sullivan was such a trainwreck that even Kennedy was mocking him.

A Pattern Among Trump's Judicial Nominees

Sullivan is not the first Trump judicial nominee to dodge the question. At an April 29 hearing, John Marck, nominated to a federal court in the Southern District of Texas, could not tell Coons what the amendment says and then declined to answer directly, calling the question more of a hypothetical.

Coons has put a version of the question to a long line of nominees. According to a running tally of responses, only two of 33 nominees had directly answered no as of that count.

The hearing came as the White House works to confirm as many conservative judges as possible before Democrats take control of the Senate. Also on Wednesday, outgoing Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas blocked a different nominee from advancing to a hearing, withholding support for Justice Department official T. Elliot Gaiser.

Reports from the hearing did not indicate when the committee would vote on Sullivan's nomination.


Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.

Explore by Topic