Jennifer GaengNov 16, 2026 5 min read

Reese’s Is Bringing Back Its 3-Pound Peanut Butter Cup Pie

The Hershey Company

Still stuck on dessert for Thanksgiving? Hershey may have an answer. Sort of.

The Reese’s brand is bringing back its supersized Reese’s Pie. It weighs more than three pounds, measures over nine inches across, and goes on sale online this week.

It’s Not Really a Pie

It looks like one. But there’s no baked crust and no traditional filling. Hershey describes it as a giant Reese’s peanut butter cup in pie form. The whole thing is made from the candy’s milk chocolate and peanut butter.

So if you were hoping for pumpkin, this isn’t it.

A Fan Favorite Returns

The Hershey Company

Reese’s first launched the pie in 2021 as a limited-time offering. By one report, Hershey made just 3,000 of them. They sold out quickly, and fans have been asking for it back ever since.

“The overwhelming response to our original Reese’s Pie proved that a fresh take on a holiday classic can create something truly special,” said Samantha Siegal, senior director of marketing for Reese’s at Hershey. She called the return “a new tradition worth celebrating.”

How to Get One

Here’s the plan.

  • When: Monday, November 16, at 9 a.m. Eastern. That’s 8 a.m. Central.

  • Where: Hershey’s online shop, at shop.hersheys.com.

  • Price: $49.99.

  • Limit: Two per order.

  • How: First come, first served, while supplies last.

You can join a waitlist now to get a reminder before the sale goes live. Hershey says some pies will also show up in limited quantities at select club stores. It didn’t say which ones.

If the first run is anything like 2021, don’t count on these sticking around.

How to Store It

Keep the pie in a cool, dry place at room temperature, away from heat and direct sunlight. Hershey says you don’t need to refrigerate it. If you do, let it warm up a bit before cutting for the best texture.

Is $49.99 a Good Deal?

The Hershey Company

Here’s a quick bit of math. At $49.99 for a little over three pounds, you’re paying roughly $16 a pound. Compare that with a regular bag of Reese’s cups at the store, and it’s pricier. But you’re paying for the novelty. It’s a centerpiece, not just candy.

How Do You Serve It?

Treat it like a real pie. Slice it into wedges.

One warning: it’s going to be rich. A nine-inch pie is usually cut into 8 to 12 slices, but this is a lot of chocolate and peanut butter, so thin slices make sense.

It could also work well alongside other desserts. A small piece next to a fruit pie balances the sweetness. Or serve it with coffee, or a scoop of vanilla ice cream, if you want to dress it up.

What Else Is Hershey Doing This Season?

Hershey’s Kisses Snickerdoodle Cookie candies
Hershey’s Kisses Snickerdoodle Cookie candies. | The Hershey Company

The pie isn’t the only holiday item. Hershey’s 2026 lineup includes new candies and popcorn inspired by Christmas movies like Elf and How the Grinch Stole Christmas. Returning favorites include Reese’s Peanut Butter Trees, Kit Kat Peppermint Stick bars, and Hershey’s Kisses Snickerdoodle Cookie candies.

Tips for Snagging One

Join the waitlist. It’s free and it’ll remind you before the sale.

Get ready ahead of time. Log in to your account and save your payment info so checkout is quick.

Be there at 9 a.m. Eastern. If you’re in Central time, that’s 8 a.m. Set an alarm.

Plan for shipping. If you’re buying for Thanksgiving, check delivery dates at checkout. It’s worth confirming it’ll arrive in time.

What If It Sells Out?

It might. The 2021 pies went fast, and this year’s are first come, first served.

Home made chocolate peanut butter cheesecake
Adobe Stock

Don’t panic. You’ve got options, and a few are easy.

Check the club stores. Hershey says some pies will show up in limited quantities at select club locations. It didn’t name which ones, so a quick call to your local store could pay off.

Make a no-bake version. A peanut butter chocolate pie doesn’t need much. Think a cookie crumb crust, a creamy peanut butter filling, and a layer of melted chocolate on top. Chop up some Reese’s cups and press them on the surface for the look.

Go the easy route. Stir chopped Reese’s cups into vanilla ice cream. Or fold them into a batch of brownies. You get the flavor without the work.

Keep a standard pie on hand. Pumpkin and pecan are Thanksgiving favorites for a reason.

Is a 3-pound peanut butter cup a Thanksgiving tradition? Maybe not yet. But for peanut butter and chocolate fans, it’s a fun alternative to the usual lineup. Just set your alarm, because it may not last.


Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.

Explore by Topic