Lead Found in 99% of Cat Foods Tested in New Investigation

If you have a cat, this one's going to make you uncomfortable. A new investigation by the nonprofit Clean Label Project tested 100 top-selling cat foods across 62 brands — wet, dry, air-dried, and freeze-dried — for more than 122 industrial and environmental contaminants. The results were hard to look at.

Lead showed up in 99% of samples. Cadmium — a metal that damages kidneys and bones — was found in 96%. Arsenic turned up in 94%. Beyond heavy metals, nearly all products also contained phthalates, the plastic chemicals linked to increased risk of death in humans, as well as glyphosate, the widely used herbicide.

"The contaminants are an ongoing exposure that may accumulate in cats' bodies over their lifetimes," said Molly Hamilton, the report's author and the Clean Label Project's executive director.

The Numbers That Stand Out

The format of the food matters significantly. Dry kibble contained roughly three times more lead than wet or air-dried products. That's a meaningful difference for cat owners who've been feeding dry food as the everyday staple because of cost or convenience.

Seafood and fish-based formulas were the worst for mercury and cadmium. Seafood wet foods contained nearly 28 times more mercury than wet foods made from other proteins. If your cat goes wild for tuna or salmon flavors, that's worth sitting with.

The Clean Label Project published a similar investigation of dog food in February that found three to 13 times more heavy metals than comparable human food. The cat food findings follow the same pattern.

Where These Contaminants Come From

Heavy metals don't end up in pet food because of carelessness. They're largely environmental — present in the soil, water, and air that food ingredients grow in or pass through.

Seafood absorbs mercury from ocean water. Grains and vegetables absorb cadmium and arsenic from soil. Lead can enter during manufacturing and from packaging.

These are systemic contamination problems that exist throughout the food supply, not unique to pet food — but the concentrations found in some cat foods exceed what's showing up in comparable human food products.

Phthalates and other plastic chemicals can migrate into food from packaging during manufacturing, storage, and transportation.

What the Industry Says

The Pet Food Institute, which represents cat food manufacturers, said in a statement that member companies "implement comprehensive food safety and quality assurance programs" and that cat food is safe. The Institute emphasized that manufacturers follow strict safety protocols.

The Clean Label Project's findings don't establish that specific products caused illness in any cats. The report measured contaminant levels against the organization's own purity benchmarks rather than FDA regulatory limits, and the FDA doesn't currently have established maximum limits for heavy metals in pet food the way it does for some human food products. Critics of the report note that benchmark — and the organization's methodology — should be considered when interpreting the findings.

What the report doesn't dispute: the contaminants are real, they're present in nearly all products tested, and chronic low-level exposure over a cat's lifetime is the concern. Cats live long lives and eat the same food repeatedly. Small amounts that wouldn't matter in a single meal accumulate into something more significant over years.

What Cat Owners Can Actually Do

The report's practical recommendations are straightforward. Rotate your cat's protein sources rather than feeding the same formula every day — this limits the accumulation of any single contaminant. If your cat currently eats primarily seafood or fish-based food, mixing in chicken or other proteins will meaningfully reduce mercury and cadmium exposure.

Wet food and air-dried products tested significantly better than dry kibble for lead levels, so if your cat tolerates wet food, shifting the balance of their diet in that direction is a reasonable step.

Ask your cat food brand directly how often they test for heavy metals and contaminants, and what their thresholds are. The brands willing to answer that question clearly are telling you something. The ones that aren't are also telling you something.

"Pet owners should take action and urge brands and retailers to ensure toxic chemicals and plastics are not hiding in cat food and its packaging," said Stefanie Babadi of the nonprofit Environmental Defense Fund, who reviewed the findings. "Pets, as part of our families, deserve food that is safe from toxic chemicals."

The Clean Label Project has posted its full findings, including brand-by-brand and product-by-product results, on its website at cleanlabelproject.org.

Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.