Hunter Tierney Jul 31, 2026 15 min read

The Colts Just Chose Ten Daniel Jones Games Over Six Years

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones (17) celebrates a touchdown with Blue on Sunday, Sept. 7, 2025, during the game at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis. The Indianapolis Colts defeated the Miami Dolphins, 33-8.
Grace Hollars/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Daniel Jones showed up to Colts training camp this week with full medical clearance and, by all accounts, no restrictions at all. That alone is great news. The fact that it comes just seven and a half months after what looked like a season-ending, career-shaking injury makes it even more striking.

Back in December, Jones tore his right Achilles in Jacksonville while already dealing with a hairline fracture in his left fibula. His first year in Indianapolis had started with real promise — an 8–2 run that briefly made the Colts look like one of the best teams in the AFC — before everything unraveled. By the time the season ended, so much of the conversation had shifted away from wins and losses and toward something simpler: were those ten games enough for Indianapolis to believe in him long-term?

Apparently, they were.

The contract Jones signed in March is technically a two-year, $88 million deal. Another $12 million is tied to wins, playing time, playoff success, and All-Pro honors. He’ll receive $50 million in cash this season, with about $60 million in total guarantees. At roughly $44 million a year before incentives, Jones now sits comfortably in the upper half of starting quarterback salaries across the league.

That isn’t bridge-quarterback money. It isn’t the kind of deal a team hands out while still shopping for its long-term answer. It’s the kind of contract that says Indianapolis already made up their mind — and now they're betting that those ten games weren’t a fluke, but a preview of what comes next.

The Ten Games Indianapolis Paid For

The numbers from Jones’ first ten games with the Colts still feel a little unreal when you say them out loud. Indianapolis went 8–2 and, for a stretch, didn’t just win games — they overwhelmed teams, averaging 31.7 points and building a +115 point differential that made the offense look less like a hot streak and more like something structurally sound. Jones was at the center of it, completing nearly 70 percent of his passes, pushing the ball for 2,659 yards at 8.3 per attempt, and accounting for 20 total touchdowns through the air and on the ground. For a while, it stopped feeling like a surprise and started feeling like an identity.

And just for context, this wasn’t normal for him. In New York, Jones had never even cleared seven yards per attempt over a full season, and his best passer rating as a Giant topped out at 92.5. So the Colts didn’t just get a slightly cleaner version of the quarterback they signed for one year and $14 million.

For those ten games, they got the best football of his career, no question.

The reasons for that aren’t exactly mysterious. In New York, Jones spent most of his time trying to survive in offenses that kept changing around him. Two head coaches, three offensive coordinators in his first few years, and an offensive line that never really settled meant he was constantly reacting instead of playing on time. The hits piled up, and eventually he started holding the ball because there just weren’t answers there to trust.

Indianapolis was the exact opposite. Everything around him actually made sense. Jonathan Taylor was playing like a wrecking ball at an MVP level — 1,139 rushing yards and 17 touchdowns through ten games. Rookie tight end Tyler Warren gave him a steady, reliable target who could line up anywhere. Michael Pittman Jr., Josh Downs, and Alec Pierce all had defined roles instead of being asked to do everything. And up front, Quenton Nelson and the offensive line gave Steichen the kind of protection that lets a play-action system actually breathe.

So Jones wasn’t being asked to carry everything anymore. His job was simpler, and honestly, more realistic: get the protection right, make the right read, put the ball where it’s supposed to go, and let the rest of the offense do their thing.

That sounds easy on paper, but it’s worth remembering how long it had been since the Colts had anything close to that at quarterback. Jones became their 11th different starter since 2019. When Steichen named him the guy, he didn’t talk about flash or hero plays — he talked about operation, protection calls, accuracy, and just running the offense the right way.

And then Jones actually did it in games. Miami and Denver came out and blitzed him on 50 dropbacks over the first two weeks — the second-highest total any quarterback had seen in an opening stretch since 2010. He responded by completing 32 of 47 passes for 455 yards and a 106.3 passer rating against those looks. By Week 8, he had been sacked just six times on 232 dropbacks and, according to PFF, hadn’t put a single turnover-worthy play on tape under pressure.

Steichen also used him in a way that actually fit. In New York, Jones was often used on designed runs just to manufacture offense. In Indianapolis, his movement was more about creating structure for everything else. On 29 play-action rollouts in those first ten games, he completed 25 passes for 262 yards. Every one of those plays forced defenses to respect Jonathan Taylor first, which gave Jones just enough space to get outside, set his feet, and throw before everything tightened up.

And maybe the biggest change was in the throws themselves. In 2022 — his best year with the Giants — Jones threw just one touchdown and five interceptions on intermediate throws between the numbers from 10 to 20 yards. Last season in Indy, he flipped that to five touchdowns and just one interception on the same type of throws.

That’s really the difference the Colts are betting on. It’s not just that Jones looked better — it’s that he looked more comfortable doing things he hadn’t consistently done before. And there’s a reason the locker room seemed to latch onto him quickly. Teammates kept talking about the same things — how early he was in the building, how late he stayed, how much time he spent with receivers after practice. Then you add in the fact that he played through two games with a broken bone in his leg, and it’s easy to see why guys believed in him.

The Colts didn’t just see a stat line; they lived with him for a year and came away convinced he was the kind of steady presence they’d been missing.

The Last Seven Years Don't Just Disappear

Sep 26, 2024; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Dallas Cowboys defensive end Marshawn Kneeland (94) reacts after sacking New York Giants quarterback Daniel Jones (8) during the third quarter at MetLife Stadium.
Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Jones is now heading into his eighth NFL season, and at this point you kind of already know the story that comes with that. The first six were long enough and messy enough that nobody really needs a full refresher on why his market bottomed out the way it did.

The Giants went 24-44-1 in his 69 regular-season starts. Jones threw 70 touchdowns and 47 interceptions and finished with an 84.3 passer rating. It’s not nothing — there were real flashes in there — but it was also never consistent enough to build on. Every time it felt like he was settling in, something would knock it off track. An injury, a turnover, a broken protection, or just an offense that couldn’t stay stable long enough to let anything breathe.

From the Colts’ point of view, the simplest explanation is that New York just wasn’t a great place to evaluate a quarterback. And honestly, that’s not wrong. The Giants cycled through coaches and seemed to always put Jones behind an offensive line that made life harder than it needed to be. When things got chaotic, his game got tighter and more hesitant. But at the same time, it’s also too easy to pretend none of it was on him. Both things can be true at once.

Even early on, the issues were there. Jones fumbled 18 times as a rookie. His 2021 season ended because of a neck injury, and the Giants declined his fifth-year option.

Then 2022 happened, and that’s where things got complicated. Brian Daboll simplified everything and really leaned into Jones’ legs, and for the first time it all looked better than average. Jones threw 15 touchdowns and just five interceptions, ran for 708 yards and seven scores, and helped lead the Giants to a 9-6-1 record and a playoff win. It was good enough that New York immediately rewarded him with a four-year, $160 million contract.

At the time, that deal felt like it was supposed to settle the debate. The Giants thought they had finally unlocked the version of Jones they always thought was in there — that one season wasn’t a fluke, but a preview.

And then reality hit again. Over the next 16 starts, the Giants went 3-13. Jones threw 10 touchdowns and 13 interceptions, dealt with another neck injury, tore his ACL, and eventually got benched to avoid triggering a $23 million injury guarantee. By November 2024, he was out of the building entirely after asking to be released.

And it's not like 2025 was perfectly linear. Jones was excellent through the first eight games, but the last stretch before the fibula fracture got messy. From Weeks 9 through 14, PFF gave him a 53.2 passing grade — third-worst among quarterbacks with at least 100 dropbacks in that span. He also led the league with 11 turnover-worthy plays over those five games. And two of those games are part of the same “ten-game sample” the Colts are now hanging their hat on.

There were some ugly moments in there. Pittsburgh forced six Colts turnovers, picked Jones off three times, and sacked him five times. A week later in Berlin, Indianapolis needed Jonathan Taylor to basically carry them to a win with 244 rushing yards and an overtime touchdown. Jones still threw for 255 yards and ran for 53, but he was also sacked seven times and fumbled three times. It was a reminder that when things start to snowball, they don't slow down.

That’s really the tension here. The Colts built an offense that fit him better than anything he’s had before, and they also leaned heavily on Jonathan Taylor to make it all work. It was a good setup, but also one that probably isn’t necessarily repeatable at that level every year.

Which is why the contract feels aggressive, even in a league where quarterback money always climbs. Baker Mayfield got three years and $100 million from Tampa Bay after a full rebound season and a playoff win. Sam Darnold got three years and $100.5 million from Seattle after throwing 35 touchdowns and winning 14 games in Minnesota. Jones got $88 million over two years — with incentives pushing it toward $100 million — after ten healthy games and an Achilles tear.

The structure matters. The shorter deal raises the annual cost, and the Colts were already staring at a $37.8 million transition tag number if they didn’t extend him. And more than anything, they know what it feels like to start over at quarterback. Once they finally found one who made Shane Steichen’s offense function the way it’s supposed to, letting him walk wasn’t really a comfortable option.

So no, Indianapolis didn’t pay Daniel Jones because they think ten games erased six years of history. They paid him because they were exhausted by the search, and because those ten games — for better or worse — convinced them they finally understood what they actually had.

Medical Clearance Isn't The Same As Proof

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones (17) smiles while talking to teammates on Sunday, Oct. 26, 2025, ahead of the game at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.
Grace Hollars/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Jones has already cleared the first real checkpoint. Over the weekend he said he feels “really good,” and Shane Steichen confirmed he’ll be a full go when the Colts open practice. That’s honestly better news than Indy probably expected back in December when he went down with the Achilles. But it also just resets things — it gets him back on the field, not back to where he was.

And that’s the tricky part with Jones. His success last year wasn’t just about standing in the pocket and throwing on schedule. A big part of what made the offense work was how he moved. The play-action game, the bootlegs, the little resets after rolling out — those weren’t extras, they were the system. He had to be able to push off, get outside the pocket, and still square up fast enough to hit receivers on the move.

He’s also been pretty open about how messy the injury situation was. That fibula issue in his left leg was bothering him for weeks, especially when he had to plant or take hits against Kansas City and Houston. And just when that started to calm down, the right Achilles popped in Jacksonville. So it wasn’t just one injury — it was basically his lower body taking turns breaking down.

Chris Ballard has been upfront too. He’s basically said not to expect the exact version of Jones we saw in that early stretch right away. The Colts still made the move because Jones is 29 and they don’t need him to be a full-time runner the way the Giants did.

But they do need him to move enough to keep the whole thing alive. And the structure looks a little different now anyway. Michael Pittman is gone to Pittsburgh. Braden Smith left after being a fixture at right tackle for years. Alec Pierce is now the top receiver on a big new deal, but he’s also starting camp on the PUP list after ankle surgery.

The core is still there, though. Jonathan Taylor's still the engine. Tyler Warren might end up being even more important in year two. Josh Downs is still one of the more reliable slot guys in the league. So it’s not like Jones is walking into a bad situation — but it’s not the exact same perfect setup he had when everything clicked last fall either.

And that’s where the pressure shifts a bit. If the Colts are paying him like a changed quarterback, then he has to actually be that guy more consistently. It can’t just be “feed Taylor and survive.” He’s going to have to keep things on schedule when the run game isn’t popping, adjust when defenses take away the easy play-action looks, and most importantly, not put the ball in harm’s way when things get messy.

Ballard called it a bet on conviction, but it’s also a bet on stability — for him and for Steichen. The Colts stuck with both of them after an 8–2 start turned into a collapse and another missed playoff run.

At some point, they stopped looking for new answers and decided this was the one they were going to ride with.

So now it all comes back to Jones. If he plays well, Indy can finally say they stopped the quarterback carousel and found something real. If he doesn’t, there’s nowhere left to point the finger. This is Steichen’s system, Ballard’s roster, and a quarterback they chose after seeing exactly how quickly things can fall apart.

All stats courtesy of NFL Pro.


Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what’s next.

Explore by Topic