Costco’s 58-Ounce Pumpkin Pie Is Back for Fall 2025

Fall is here, and so is one of Costco’s most beloved desserts. 

The 58-ounce Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie has officially returned to bakery shelves, marking the unofficial start of Thanksgiving season. 

The pie’s size, price, and nostalgic flavor make it a must-have for gatherings big and small.

The Size and the Savings

Costco’s pumpkin pie is a bakery legend for a reason. Weighing in at nearly four pounds, it’s more than double the size of most grocery store versions. 

And, at just $5.99 to $6.80, depending on your location, it’s also one of the most affordable desserts you can buy for the holidays. 

Shoppers often say one pie easily serves a dozen people, with plenty left over for your morning coffee and cream the next day.

Why Everyone’s Obsessed

Fans describe the pie as smooth, spiced, and perfectly balanced. The filling is creamy without being heavy, and the flaky crust holds up even after a day or two in the fridge.

Many people slice and freeze pieces for later, while others mix a spoonful into Costco’s food court soft serve for a quick DIY pumpkin sundae. 

Some blend leftover slices into milkshakes for a creamy holiday dessert, while others crumble the pie into parfait layers with whipped cream or yogurt.

You can also cube and toast the crust into sweet croutons for ice cream or fold small chunks into pancake batter for a breakfast twist. 

And, if you’re feeling ambitious, you can even swirl a few spoonfuls into brownie batter for an easy pumpkin-chocolate treat.

When and Where to Find It

The pumpkin pie usually appears in early September and remains through Thanksgiving, though stock will vary by store. 

Some warehouses sell out early in the season, prompting members to grab an extra and freeze it. But, you can always check your local availability online or by calling your nearest store.

Why It’s Become a Seasonal Icon

The return of this pie has become a signal that autumn has officially arrived. It joins other seasonal favorites like apple cider, butternut squash soup, and fall-scented candles, making it one of Costco’s most recognizable holiday staples. 

It also joins another fan-favorite, Trader Joe’s, as they usher in the season with a cartful of pumpkin snacks to help us savor the season. 

How to Store and Serve

Costco’s pie will keep well for three days in the refrigerator or up to a month in the freezer when wrapped tightly. 

Try serving it chilled with whipped cream or gently warmed with vanilla ice cream. If you’re hosting a party, you can also cut smaller slices to serve more guests and avoid food waste.

We hope this list inspires a few quick Thanksgiving dessert ideas. Costco’s 58-ounce pumpkin pie captures the cozy, cheerful spirit of the season. It’s big enough for a family feast, affordable enough for all our budgets, and beloved enough to mark the true taste of fall.

Did you find this information useful? Feel free to bookmark or to post to your timeline to share with your friends.