Hunter Tierney Mar 10, 2025 4 min read

Deadly Play: When Game Night Became a Crime Scene

Credit: Platte County Missouri Sheriff's Office

On January 7, 2024, three men - Ricky Johnson, David Harrington, and Clayton McGeeney - were found dead in a Kansas City backyard after watching a Chiefs game. Initially, police suspected no foul play, but social media speculation led to further investigation.

Over a year later, Jordan Willis and Ivory Carson were charged with involuntary manslaughter and distributing controlled substances. The cause of death was a lethal mix of fentanyl and cocaine. Evidence linked Willis to cocaine and Carson to fentanyl.

Despite the charges, both men claim innocence. The victims' families express frustration with the investigation and seek justice.


It was supposed to be just another Sunday watching the Chiefs play, but what happened after the game on January 7, 2024, turned into a tragedy that's haunted the Kansas City community ever since. 

Just two days later, police found the bodies of Ricky Johnson, David Harrington, and Clayton McGeeney in the backyard of Jordan Willis' home — exactly where they'd been cheering for their team.

Initially, authorities didn't see anything suspicious, quickly stating that "no foul play" was suspected. But that quick judgment didn't sit right with the families, and soon enough, social media was buzzing with speculation. Platforms like X and TikTok exploded with theories and frustration as people wondered why there were more questions than answers.

Charges Finally Filed, Answers Slowly Emerge

Credit: Ricky Johnson Facebook

Fast forward more than a year, and the case took a major turn. On March 5, 2025, prosecutors charged two men — Jordan Willis and Ivory Carson — with involuntary manslaughter and distribution of controlled substances. Both Willis and Carson face serious time, with each charge potentially landing them in prison for up to 10 years. They're both currently sitting behind bars with a hefty $100,000 cash bond keeping them there.

The turning point in this investigation was the forensic report, which revealed the tragic cause of death: a lethal mix of fentanyl and cocaine. Investigators discovered two separate bags of drugs in Willis' home — one with cocaine and the other with fentanyl. DNA evidence pointed directly to Willis as the source of cocaine and Carson as the one who brought fentanyl into the picture.

Witnesses provided chilling details, recalling cocaine being passed around during the Chiefs game. One even described Willis supplying a large plate of cocaine, painting a disturbing picture of what unfolded that day. 

The evidence didn't end there, text messages seemed to confirm Carson's involvement in supplying drugs to at least one of the victims, Harrington, adding another layer to the troubling narrative.

The Defense: Claims of Innocence

Even with all the evidence stacking up, both men are standing firm, saying they've done nothing wrong. Willis' lawyer, John Picerno, is adamant his client had nothing to do with supplying or buying drugs. Willis himself says he last saw the three friends leaving his house and had no idea anything was wrong, let alone that their lives were in danger.

Ivory Carson's stance is slightly different. He openly admitted selling cocaine to the victims but said it was prior to January 1, 2024 — well before the fatal gathering.

Families Demand Justice and Clarity

Jan 29, 2023; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; A general view outside Arrowhead Stadium before the AFC Championship game between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Cincinnati Bengals.
Jan 29, 2023; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; A general view outside Arrowhead Stadium before the AFC Championship game between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Cincinnati Bengals. | Credit: Denny Medley-Imagn Images

Behind these headlines are grieving families still trying to process an unimaginable loss. Theresa Harrington, David's mother, expressed frustration over feeling sidelined by authorities throughout the investigation. Telling the Daily Mail, "They wouldn't tell me anything." She went on to add: 

"You know, this won't go to trial for a year-and-a-half,' she lamented. [I] still don't know anything about how my son died or his last moments"

Meanwhile, Ricky Johnson’s father made a firm commitment to be present at every single court date, determined not to let his son's memory fade.

While Theresa openly acknowledged her son’s drug use, she passionately argued he never intended harm, highlighting peer pressure as a likely factor that played a tragic role.

Looking Ahead

As this case moves forward, it underscores just how quickly life can change — and how painstaking the search for justice can be. The Kansas City community, along with the families who've lost so much, remain cautiously hopeful as they brace for more hearings in the future.

At the end of the day, this isn't just about a football game or even criminal charges — it's about real people, devastating loss, and the ongoing battle to make sure justice is brought to these families.

Explore by Topic